This week’s lecture discussed the ‘battle’ between open and closed operating systems through the example of Apple iPhones and Android phones. While this may seem like a pretty standard debate, Ted talks in depth about the operating systems and their philosophies themselves rather than just whether the iPhone or an Android phone is better.
The thing that caught my attention the most was the stark differences between Google and Apple’s goals; with the Android being targeted as such an open-source system that the company actually relinquished their control over the platform, user base and the content which it contains, while Apple devices remaining a closed-off system where Apple controls everything: the apps, the user base, and its iOS operating system.
Now, you have to wonder which philosophy is actually better?
Both Android and Apple iOS is widely popular today, and while Apple makes my preferred devices, I do admit that I agree more heavily with Android’s philosophy and business model.
Reference List
Mitew, T 2017, ‘iOS VS Android: The Two Futures of the Mobile Net’, University of Wollongong, YouTube Video, available via: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QlWYsoi0SZ8&list=PLiPp71qLKusVlNLCiUmumvTeArECcETMc&index=24&t=0s>
Nicole Gentle 
The differing models make for a very interesting debate, and makes even the best of Apple lovers sway towards agreeing that Android has a better model. Nobody likes being controlled!
LikeLike
Personally it’s difficult to say which one is “better” having only trying Apple products. However, whilst Android has a lot of freedom within their model, it could be safe to say that it could get out of control, in comparison to Apples restricted, yet reviewed and controlled model. Users may feel that Apples model is more official as its controlled and created by “someone important”. Check out this article https://us.norton.com/internetsecurity-mobile-android-vs-ios-which-is-more-secure.html It discusses how although Android’s app market is more open, it’s important to consider which apps you download as some ask for access to contacts, social media etc.
However, having an open source model would be really helpful for people who are wanting to build their own computers and customise apps for their own use. In the long run, having numerous copies of open source models may be beneficial and may out run Apple’s restricted model. I think it would be effective to include some links to different sources into your blog, even the one I have included into this comment. I liked how you admitted that you agree with Android’s philosophy, as I probably would have to agree with you as well. Yet I also only have Apple products…Maybe the Apple meme has gotten the better of us!
LikeLike